A collection of Short Stories for you to Enjoy.
Written by Marilyn Anne Pate.
Finding Emma Lucille *** Dear Mama, *** This year, as always, I began to dread Christmas. Everyone else was happy and excited. I was heavy yet brittle—a hollow, easily shattered ornament. For my family’s sake I went through the motions. What could I do to make this year different? I gathered what I’d learned of my mother and wrote the letter I’d promised.
*** Now that it’s on paper I find there’s a sense of knowing her in ways I never felt before. I just had to go inside myself, look at my children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren to find her. This year when I visited Evergreen Cemetery I took the letter and tucked it between her headstone and the poinsettias.
We stopped at the cemetery office for a map. The simple granite tombstone in section C, row 3, plot 9, with her name and 1909-1940— made her real. She wasn’t a dream, a dimly remembered story or a faded movie memory. I was five when she died.
I placed a pink poinsettia next to the stone. Had she liked pink? It would have gone well with her red hair. The pale, desert December sunlight dappled through old, grown tall elms. My heart raced and I trembled as a soft breeze caressed my wet cheeks.
My husband put his arms around me, "Lucille, this is your daughter. You would have been proud of her. You have three grandchildren and four great-grandchildren. They are loving, good, young people. We wish you could have known them."
As we walked to the car I thought of my long search for Emma Lucille. I decided to write her a letter.
You waved from the city bus as you left to go downtown to the parade celebrating the premier of the first movie filmed at Old Tucson. It was the biggest happening in our little city since the railroad came to town.
Aunt Winnie volunteered to care for three year old Freddie and me. "Lucille, you love movies and theatre. You’ll have more fun without your kids tagging along. Remember everything so you can tell us all about it."
That evening, as we snuggled on the couch, you told us about your day. "I saw Jean Arthur and William Holden, the stars of ARIZONA, in their Cadillac convertible move slowly along Stone Avenue. Stagecoaches and antique wagons, pulled by teams of shiny black horses, were filled with local dignitaries—even the governor was there. The University Wildcats marching band thrilled us and we cheered. Huge banners hung high across the parade route. Light poles were wrapped with red, white and blue bunting.
"Congress Street was blocked to traffic and covered with sand. An Indian village, half sized Presidio Fort, front only saloons and old time merchant shops lined Congress from Stone to Fourth Avenue The cool breeze, low clouds and slight drizzle didn’t dampen our enthusiasm.
"It was thrilling!! I can’t wait to see the movie. The premier’s price is too high. We’ll go in a week or two. I’m worn out. Too much excitement for one day," you said as you tucked us in.
No one knew that in less than a month you would be in a hospital fighting for your life. On that cool, wet morning, you caught a cold and developed pneumonia. Daddy’s mother, Grandma Mary, was called to come from the ranch in New Mexico.
On December 21st Daddy drove me to St. Mary’s Hospital. We passed through downtown where brightly colored lights adorned buildings and lamp posts. Shoppers gathered at the large windows of Steinfeld’s, Levy’s and Jacome’s Department Stores to admire glistening animated holiday scenes. Christmas carols floated through the frosty air. I was scared while everyone else was happy. Daddy was silent.
Because children weren’t allowed in hospitals unless they were sick, Daddy held me up so I could look through a window into your room. I saw you lying in a bed enclosed in white gauzy cloth that I believe was an oxygen tent.
I wanted to give you a kiss or hold your hand. Did you know I was there? Your eyes were closed. Your red hair spilled across the pillow—the only color in an otherwise white room.
On the drive home it started to rain. The desert dry windshield wipers stuttered and shrieked. Squeak, squeak, back and forth. Was it the rain or my tears that blurred the Christmas lights?
After you died, two days before Christmas, Daddy had a big fight with Aunt Winnie about a funeral. There were no services. It would be ten years before I was allowed to see your two sisters and my cousins.
Death was no stranger to Grandma Mary—a pioneer ranch woman who had buried many friends and kin. She and Daddy handled grief by ignoring it and getting on with what had to be done.
I wondered if any one else noticed you were gone. I’d hide behind the door, listening to the grownups, hoping one of them would say something about you. Perhaps then I’d know you were real and not a dream. I was surprised that others couldn’t see the cannon-ball sized hole where my stomach used to be. They should have been able to look right through me. My questions made adults uncomfortable so I stopped asking about you.
No one allowed or taught me how to grieve. If only someone had said, "It’s all right to be sad. A sad thing has happened. Your Mama didn’t want to leave you. She loved you very much." Instead, I was told, "Don’t cry. Big girls don’t cry. It’s over and done with; water under the bridge. Smile. Be happy."
I swallowed my tears and smiled. My feelings were wrong so I stuffed them down into the big hole. "You are such a happy smiling little girl," grownups said. They didn’t know how I cried myself to sleep, the awful stomachaches and the guilt.
Grandma visited with a neighbor on the front porch while I played nearby, "Lucille had a bad heart. She shouldn’t have had children. I don’t know how she survived her birth. She was a big baby, nearly eight pounds. Then Freddie came along two years later."
It was my fault. I made you die. To make up for my wickedness I promised myself to take care of Freddie, excel in school and never, ever do anything wrong again. I became the family peacemaker and did my best to make everybody happy. I carried the burden of Grandma’s casual remark well into adulthood.
Daddy remarried when I was eight and we often went to the cemetery on Oracle Road to visit the graves of Mama JB’s father and sister. I knew you were there but I didn’t know where. I’d look furtively around hoping to find your grave. I never did. Then I went home and had a stomach ache. The years passed and my memories faded but in times of stress my need for you surfaced.
When I married, when our three children were born, when I graduated from college with my husband and our three teenagers cheering for me—I wanted, I needed you.
In my middle age I gathered my courage and set out to find you. The person to start with was your husband, my father. He was arrogant, bombastic and a shameless liar. His third marriage was a shambles. I saw little of him. I threw caution to the wind and asked the forbidden. Did he see any of you in me? What did you do for fun? How did you dress, walk, laugh? What had you looked like? I had no photos, no letters, no keepsakes.
"She was an excellent typist. I always thought you were more like me than her."
"I’ve heard she had a bad heart. What can you tell me about that?" I pressed.
"She was born with a heart defect. They called them blue babies. No treatment in those days. Her mother said she was surprised Lucille lived long enough to graduate from college. I didn’t know about her problems when we dated at Flagstaff. It wasn’t until we lived at Fort Grant that she complained. Altitude was too high," he said. "Think I have a box of pictures and a few of her things somewhere. Maybe out in the shed. Never knew you were interested."
On my next visit, he gave me a battered, dusty carton that had somehow survived the many moves of his mangled life. The pictures, letters, beaded purse, wristwatch, round rimless eyeglasses—common everyday things to anyone else, were treasures to me. When I perched the glasses on my nose and looked through them I moved into another dimension. You had worn them, looked at the world through them, wiped and cleaned them and put them carefully into their hard blue marbled case.
Art nouveau costume jewelry fell out of a decaying heart shaped candy box. When I cautiously opened my baby book and for the first time, saw your handwriting I came unglued. I wept. Torrents of long denied grief wracked my body.
Through tear swollen eyes I opened a frayed manila envelope. It contained typewritten stories. You liked to write! One was stamped and addressed to Collier’s Magazine.
I had always wanted to write but was never encouraged to follow my instincts. Your stories told me my father was wrong. There was a lot of you in me and there was nothing wrong or hoity-toity about wanting to put words on paper.
The pictures showed you wearing fashionable clothes. You were about 5’8” tall and slim. One set was taken of you wearing the Juliet costume in a college production of Romeo and Juliet.
From Aunt Winnie, I learned you wanted to be called Lucille instead of Emma. You were born on March 9, 1909 in Hot Springs, Arkansas, graduated from Phoenix Union High School and four years later, Arizona State Teachers College at Flagstaff, Arizona in June 1930.
Dad said, "We were married on June 15, 1932 in Gallup, New Mexico. The Justice of the Peace was celebrating his appointment and was happily tipsy. We were his first wedding."
Who else could I ask about you? Aunt Christine and Grandma Mary were gone. My cousins barely remembered you.
I struggled to find the essence of you. Occasionally, I caught a hint of fragrance, a trace of nutmeg on a glass of eggnog or an echo of laughter that was gone by the time I became conscious of it. I couldn’t capture and hold those elusive moments.
I wish I knew what your favorite perfume was, what your voice sounded like, what food and music you preferred. I looked at the pictures, the letters and stories and tried to wring some warmth, some scent, some awareness of you out of inert pieces of brittle yellow paper. I failed.
Gradually, I realized you have always been with me. You must have been there through those traumatic years of growing up. How else to explain my academic achievements, my spunk in defying my father and marrying the love of my life—all despite the physical and emotional abuse that filled the houses I lived in?
I catch glimpses of you in our three children. Kerry has a joyful laugh, a love of the theatre and a warm understanding nature that overlies the inner steel that has brought her to the top of her profession. Tracy is sentimental, caring and a great typist! She enjoys beautiful things and has a loving home and a wide circle of creative friends. Duncan has long lanky legs, a certain angle to his cheekbones and is a world class story teller. Our only granddaughter, Christine, is the image of you—the same cleft chin, the shy smile and the sober eyes.
Thank you for having the courage to give birth to me. I love you.
Your Daughter
My search was over. I had found Emma Lucille Jaeger McNeill.
Emma Lucille Jaeger McNeill
1909 - 1940
circa 1931 - 22 years young.
*********************
Marilyn and Terry insisted on a church wedding because they were proud of their love and wanted to let the world know. They had been forced to sneak around far too long. They planned and paid for the simple ceremony. His parents were supportive and his mother made the white lace gown Marilyn wore. For a fee, the ladies of the church provided the cake and punch and served guests in the patio of the church.
The years pass, the hair grows sparse and grays. The knees stiffen, the eyes weaken and water while the mind grows clogged with modern technology. Yet, through it all they have learned to depend on me. To those who ask "How have you managed to survive for so long?" I say, "I look back with wonder and joy. We three were blessed with good health, a sense of purpose, ambition and direction. They know there is a God, a power greater than they and that most of the time they are not in control. My two are as different as storm and sunshine but they love. They love each other, their children and life. Each marriage is different, each finds its own way. We have been lucky, we worked hard and were determined to see it through (Some say we are stubborn)".*********************


*********************
